The New-Denison Hotel, as it was originally known, was reportedly named for two of the investors, John Chalfant New and a Cincinnati businessman named John Denison. A previous project on the site, the Sheets Hotel, had been launched in 1870, however, it languished. Only the first four floors of the building were standing when fire nearly destroyed it in 1874. Judge E. B. Martindale joined New and Denison in the purchase of the charred remains, and H. B. Sherman of Milwaukee built the prestigious hotel on the ruins at the corner of Ohio and Pennsylvania streets. It opened in 1880.

A square, six-story building in the style of a French country manor house.
Denison Hotel, 1905 Credit: Bass Photo Co Collection, Indiana Historical Society View Source

In the early 1890s, D. P. Erwin purchased the property and added more stories and a mansard roof. The six-story hotel boasted 250 rooms and a number of amenities, including a billiard room and bar. The dining rooms were popular with local residents, who could purchase Sunday dinners for 75 cents.

The hotel was well known for its political connections. Both the Republican Party and Democratic Party state organizations had headquarters there for a time. Before and during legislative sessions, the Denison was the site of party caucuses and closed-door negotiations. Political schemes were hatched in Parlor A on the second floor or in the “Amen Corner,” a secluded nook in the lobby.

The yellowed envelope has an image of the hotel and "The New Denison Hotel Co." on it.
Envelope for the New-Denison Hotel, 1913 Credit: Indiana Historical Society View Source

By the 1920s, the hotel had become less popular. Norman A. Perry and Ruth (Perry) Griffith, who were heirs of Charles Coffin Perry, purchased the Denison. With automobiles, they realized the need to provide more parking in downtown Indianapolis and identified the Denison Hotel’s location as an ideal place to build a parking garage. They razed the building in 1933.

Named after the hotel, Denison Service Parking, one of the earliest paid parking facilities in the U.S., opened on March 29, 1934. The Perry and Griffith families subsequently built other parking garages in the city and kept the name, Denison Parking. The company remains in the hands of the Griffith family. It operates 69 parking facilities across Indianapolis and has locations in such cities as Las Vegas, Denver, Minneapolis, Ft. Myers, and Pompano Beach.

The neoclassical lobby is divided with a row of three arches. There are coffered ceiling, classical columns and an ornate tile floor.
Denison Hotel interior, ca. 1916 Credit: The Indiana Album: Evan Finch Collection View Source

Named after the hotel, Denison Service Parking, one of the earliest paid parking facilities in the U.S., opened on March 29, 1934. The Perry and Griffith families subsequently built other parking garages in the city and kept the name, Denison Parking. The company remains in the hands of the Griffith family. It operates 69 parking facilities across Indianapolis and has locations in such cities as Las Vegas, Denver, Minneapolis, Ft. Myers, and Pompano Beach.

Revised February 2021
CONTRIBUTE

Help improve this entry

Contribute information, offer corrections, suggest images.

You can also recommend new entries related to this topic.